Just wanted to clarify the Cranky Product Manager’s previous post on training.
The Cranky Product Manager is NOT against training for product managers. Not at all.
In fact, she HEARTS training, and any effort product professionals make to improve their skills and knowledge. There are some really great classes out there! (see note 1)
It’s the PASSIVE nature of the ‘sit-back-and-train-me’ attitude that drives the Cranky Product Manager bonkers. Especially when used as an excuse for not getting the job done.
The Cranky Product Manager says this as someone who has supervised a fair number of product managers: if you want to use ‘lack of training’ as an excuse, your performance review had better NOT be the first time your boss hears about your training needs.
Instead, you should have been making the business case for training as soon as you concluded your skill gaps were getting in the way.
Now, here’s the Cranky Product Manager’s recipe for “Convincing your boss to give you training.” It works. Really. Well a lot of the time (probably not in early-stage startups).
1. Make a 30 minute appointment with your boss.
2. Go into this 30 minute appointment with a half-page, bulleted printed handout that he/she can review. This handout should make the case for getting you trained and give your boss several options to consider.
3. If you’re stuck, structure your doc according to a classic “Situation, Complication, Recommendation” outline.
Situation:
- The specific skills you already have
- Where you would like to be, and why your boss should agree that this is a good goal for you. (maybe refer to a previous performance review)
Complication:
- The gap between your current skills and where you want to be
- If you were to remedy this gap, how would the company benefit? What’s in it for your boss? In which release would your boss’s life improve, due to your improved skills?
Recommendations:
- List a few different options for closing the skill gap (bosses love to pick from different options). For each, list the pros/cons, the cost, and the time frame.
- The Cranky PM recommends that you suggest at least one option that involves no budget but instead involves time.
- For example, your boss could tutor you in this specific skill and meet with you once or twice a week. In proposing this option, you should be very specific about how often you’d want to meet and what you would need from the boss (without seeming too needy). Example: (provide face-to-face feedback on the latest version of my product strategy document once a week, help me brainstorm how to segment the market, give me a lollipop and a “you’re a SUPERSTAR” sticker at the end, etc).
- Note that the bigger the time commitment needed for your “free” option, the more likely your boss is to pick another option.
- Make sure you highlight which option YOU recommend and why.
- Acknowledge that there are several constraints at play: budget, release schedules, who will pick up the slack while you sit in training, etc. Explain how you will minimize these impacts.
4. Go over the handout in the meeting. Get your boss nodding “yes” as you mention each point. Hopefully that yes-nodding will get her/his neck limbered up, and s/he will also agree to one of your training options.
5. If your boss immediately picks an option, great. Go back to your desk, write an email to the boss saying something “Thanks for meeting with me today. We agreed that I should sign up for training class X.” Then go sign up. Hurry. (But pray there is a decent cancellation policy if your boss is one of those people who changes his/her mind every 3 minutes).
If your boss wants more time to think about it, do NOT leave the meeting without nailing down a time frame for a decision. Immediately set a meeting for follow-up.
6. Remember, NO WHINING! No “you owe me.” Keep focused on the benefits of your training to YOUR BOSS and the company.
7. If the boss says “no,” be mature about it. Try to understand why. Then go educate yourself as directed in the previous post, using all the resources of the online PM community. And then, in a few months, try again.
Now, you might worry that all this would be pestering and annoying to your boss. That’s a valid worry. But more likely is that your boss would be 20% annoyed (because now s/he has to make a decision and maybe spend some money) and 80% patting him/herself on the back for hiring such a high-potential, results-focused product manager. Because the way you approach the training issue shows how you would also approach the rest of your job.
Note 1: The Cranky Product has partaken of many training opportunities (a self-funded MBA, Product Camps, UC Extension, Pragmatic Marketing), but her employers never paid. Apparently, she did not master the above-described technique until too late in her career, when she became the boss and found herself on the receiving end.






{ 22 comments… read them below or add one }
Well now that you’ve clarified your position, I’ll have to trash the post I was writing about part 2 of your series. It was entitled: Why the CrankyPM is sooooo wrong about Product Manager training.
I was going to write that based on what you were saying, not only do PMs not need training, but they don’t even need desks or computers. PMs who ask for those luxuries must be wimps who don’t know that Product Managers don’t need anything but their own sweat and neurons to get things done.
But now that you’ve clarified your position, you really should rename your previous post to something like:
“No excuse Product Management: If you can’t even ask your manager for training when you need it, you should find another profession”
Saeed, all will be well in the universe as soon as you realize that THE CRANKY PRODUCT MANAGER IS ALWAYS RIGHT. Even if you think she’s not right, sit tight and wait, because in the end she always is.
This post proves it, no?
:-)
You are right when you agree with me, which is certainly true in this case. :-)
Saeed
What is that bizarro image you selected as your gravatar?
Another thought. The Cranky Product Manager has decided you need a nickname, given you are her frequent nemesis. (But in a good, respectful, and intelligent way.)
How about the Anti-Cranky PM? Or the Contrarian PM? Or the Canadian PM? Or the Wrathful PM (get it? “Wrath of Khan”? ha ha ha so freakin’ hilarious and clever isn’t it)?
Wrath of Khan — that was funny….. 25 years ago!!
But if you found that funny, this’ll leave you in stitches:
http://www.khaaan.com
As for a nickname — I’ve never been fond of them — but sticking with the Star Trek theme, I think I relate best with Spock. So Logical PM seems appropriate.
Hey…this just gave me an idea for a blog post. Thanks. :-)
As for the gravatar, its’ kind of like an all-seeing eye. Something very help to anyone, including PMs. But it’s not an evil eye like the eye of Sauron. Need to make that caveat up front. :-)
Another caveat. (a caveat on a caveat, this is).
If you got the job by claiming you were very experienced at product launches and have done it X times, expect your boss to be a bit puzzled if you ask for training on product launches.
The Cranky Product Manager doesn’t think there should be any problem with asking for training, provided you did not misrepresent yourself to get the job.
Being right all the time is pretty tough isn’t it? :-)
Au contraire, it is extremely easy. Because it is who the Cranky Product Manager IS.
I’ll await your clarification/caveat on this last point before commenting further.
OK, another caveat.
Be prepared for your boss to say “no” and don’t act like a petulant child if you are denied. Be a grown-up. State exactly what you want, but be mature enough to hear “no.”
And in no’s the word, just suck it up, buttercup. No whining. No excuses. Proceed to educate yourself as outlined in the previous post.
#prodmgmt – New Cranky Blog Post! : Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training http://bit.ly/cWKrMP
RT @crankypm: #prodmgmt – New Cranky Blog Post! : Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training http://bit.ly/cWKrMP
RT @crankypm: #prodmgmt – New Cranky Blog Post! : Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training http://bit.ly/cWKrMP
Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training: Shared by Rian
Why oh why is this woman … http://bit.ly/9UTvIf
That, as Saeed pointed out, is a totally different post – and the right approach if you’re not one of those “I was born knowing everything” dudes.
I did (almost) exactly that a few months ago, and went from “maybe” to “not now” to “not there” to “yes, go and sign up”.
Now I need the training itself to actually happen and see if it was worth it.
Do I get a nickname too?
Geez, CPM – time to start using one of those little pill organizers, cuz you’re not taking the right meds at the right time. Or at least self-medicate with less than a bottle of sour-mash before posting. (Disclaimer – I’m not a doctor, and if that sounded like medical advice, then obviously you aren’t either.)
One moment, we’re all having a chummy time talking about how much life sucks (a favorite pastime of PMs). The next moment, you’re crackin’ skulls, calling out the whiners and moaners. It’s like having your pimp lecture you for your lack of morals.
Count me among those who thought you went off the deep end with your last post, and now you’re going bipolar with a pro-training rant. Tsk, tsk.
Let me regale you with a tale from yester-year, when dot-coms were still retardedly exciting, Weezer was new and exciting, and blue-haired, goateed, one-word-named programmers (e.g. “my name is Rocket”) still roamed the halls of the Fortune 500.
I was blessed with a PM career that started in a team that had the most experienced PMs formally assigned as mentors to the new PMs, we had a list of areas of responsibility, expectations for performance in those areas at each PM level, and a regular rotation of those responsibilities. That program of mentoring and regular rotation was the bomb. Everyone on the PM team definitely had their strengths in certain areas, but everyone could also pitch-in for any area and pull their weight. I had no idea at the time how freakin’ unicorn-ishly rare and wonderful that situation was (*sigh*).
I strongly, STRONGLY encourage mentorship for new PMs and task rotation throughout one’s career. I was fortunate to have had a good skill set by the time I went through PragMktg and Sequent, and both times I went through as part of teams that had both oldies and newbies. And the newbies all enjoyed the few days of training and felt giddy about how wonderful their role can be, but then they all hit a wall of despair when they realized they didn’t know how to get their daily reality to be like the fun flip-chart world of the training program. Mentorship helps newbies learn and apply skills over time with continuous opportunities for feedback, and if you’re lucky enough to get $$ for formal training, mentorship after the event helps ensure that $$ doesn’t dribble out of newbies’ heads at the bar after the sales kick-off / product launch / or whatever else drives your corporate cohorts to drink until they can’t thumb-type their crackberries anymore.
Not to mention, if you’re a PM manager (e.g. Director of PM, VP of PM, whatever), you’ll look like a tool if you keep hiring new PMs and they all either wind-up transferring or quitting and their exit-interviews keep echoing phrases like “boss is clueless”, “never knew what I was supposed to do”, and “made me feel like cutting myself every day”.
Oh well, that’s my two-cents. Now if Saeed can kindly convert that to Canadian currency…
- Paco
(PS – that Khaan site is the shiz-nite)
Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training – http://crankypm.com/2010/06/quick-clarification-convince-boss-training/
RT @crankypm: Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training ##prodmgmt http://bit.ly/cWKrMP
RT @jezzaman03: RT @crankypm: Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training ##prodmgmt http://bit.ly/cWKrMP
I wrote a comment for your original post. Maybe should have been here. Oh well.
Going through this now. RT @crankypm: Quick Clarification and How to Convince Your Boss to Get You Training ##prodmgmt http://bit.ly/9UTvIf